|

5 Best Cat Foods Without Fish Your Cat Will Love

Disclaimer: As a Chewy and Amazon affiliate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This does not impact our reviews and comparisons.

Looking for cat foods without fish? It’s hard to find cat food that doesn’t use fish or fish-oil.

Not to worry, I’ve rounded up the best fish-free options your cat will love, including my top 5.

  1. Feline Natural Chicken & Lamb Feast | Best Overall
  2. Wellness Core Tiny Tasters Duck | Best for Picky Eaters
  3. Wellness Smooth Chicken Loaf | Most Affordable
  4. Ziwi Peak Air-Dried Lamb | Best Dry Cat Food
  5. Tiki Cat Born Carnivore | Most Affordable Dry Cat Food

A lot cats are fish lovers, but some don’t fare well due to allergies. You might also want to cut out tuna due to mercury.

Either way, you’re after a fish-free cat food that tickles your felines fancy. That can be hard with the range of fishy cat foods out there that drizzle in fish oil.

But don’t worry, in this article I’ve narrowed down the best fish-free cat food your cat will love.

I’ve also included a buying guide to help you find fish-free cat food. I’ll also answer frequently asked questions about fish and your cats health.

I am a cat enthusiast and independent researcher. I am not a veterinarian and I recommend seeking the advice of a vet for any further questions. The advice in this article is not intended as medical advice.

Let’s get into the article.

5 Best Cat Foods Without Fish

Buying Guide

Not sure how to find great fish-free cat food?

The first place to start is the ingredients list. Whilst the front label usually tells you about fish (e.g. salmon), it’s not a guarantee.

Some brands don’t even tell you much about what ingredients on the front label at all!

So whilst you can start by looking on the front of the label, always double check the fine print.

Fish ingredients include:

  • Fish
  • Fish meal
  • Tilapia
  • Tuna
  • Salmon
  • Hoki
  • Mackerel
Cat food ingredients list
Check the ingredients list for fish ingredients (this one uses tuna oil…can you see it?)

What about meat by-products? This is a vague food source.

Usually meat by-products don’t include fish, but I don’t have faith in that.

If you want to be extra careful, steer clear of cat food with vague ingredients like meat by-products.

Another thing you’ll want to be mindful of is fish or salmon oil. This can also cause allergies!

You’ll usually find this ingredient lower on the ingredient list so be careful.

Aside from avoiding fish, you’ll want a generally healthy food that meets your cats dietary needs.

Look for the statement of nutritional adequacy from AAFCO.

For kittens (<1 years) look for cat food that meets needs for growth or all life stages. Adults (1-7 years) should be fed food that meets the needs for maintenance.

Learn More:

5 Best Cat Foods Without Fish

I’ve narrowed this list down to the 5 top picks. I’ve tested three of these options with my cats or have experience with other products from the brand.

If none of these options tickle your fancy, scroll down for a full comparison of fish free wet cat foods to check out.

1. Feline Natural Chicken & Lamb Feast

Healthiest Wet Cat Food Without Fish

Pros and Cons

  • No fish or fish oils!
  • No added grains or soy
  • High in protein
  • Pricey
  • Mixed taste reviews

Feline Natural is the healthiest cat food that avoid sneaking in fish or any oils. Hard to go past it for cats of all life stages.

As a cat food, Feline Naturals wet pouches are perfection. No grains, soy or fillers. I find it hard not to recommend this cat food for anyone wanting the best for their cats health.

We tested Feline Natural with our cats who had mixed feelings as with some reviews online. If you’ve got a finnicky eater, give this one time. It’s also pricey.

Key Features:

  • Suitable for all life stages
  • Made in New Zealand
  • Wet pate cat food in a pouch

Read More: Feline Natural Cat Food Review

>> Check price of Feline Natural Chicken & Lamb (Chewy) <<

>> Check price of Feline Natural Chicken & Lamb (Amazon) <<

>> Check price of Feline Natural Chicken & Lamb (Only Natural Pet) <<

Feline Natural Chicken & Lamb nutrition information (dry matter analysis)
Feline Natural Chicken & Lamb nutrition information (dry matter analysis)
A close up look at Feline Natural Chicken & Lamb
A close up look at Feline Natural Chicken & Lamb

2. Wellness Core Tiny Tasters Duck

Best Cat Food Without Fish for Picky Eaters

Pros and Cons

  • Yep…there’s no fish or fish oils!
  • Suitable for all life stages
  • Great for picky eaters
  • Added gums
  • A little pricey as well

If you’ve got a picky eater, try Wellness Core Tiny Tasters. Our cats loved it, and it’s worth a look if you’ve got a die hard fish lover that won’t budge.

As far as nutrition goes, everything checks out with Wellness Core. It’s low in carbs and high in animal ingredients. Great for all life stages.

Only downside is the price. It also uses gums, which might test a sensitive stomach.

Key Features:

  • Suitable for all life stages
  • Made in the USA
  • Wet pate cat food in a pouch

Read More: Wellness Core Cat Food Review

>> Check price of Wellness Core Tiny Tasters Duck (Amazon) <<

>> Check price of Wellness Core Tiny Tasters Duck (Chewy) <<

Wellness Core Tiny Tasters Duck nutrition information (dry matter analysis)
Wellness Core Tiny Tasters Duck nutrition information (dry matter analysis)
A close up look at Wellness Core Tiny Tasters Duck
A close up look at Wellness Core Tiny Tasters Duck (pate style)

3. Wellness Smooth Chicken Loaf

Best Affordable Wet Cat Food Without Fish

Pros and Cons

  • No fish!
  • Suitable for all life stages
  • Grain-free
  • Added gums
  • Only for adult cats

A more affordable fish-free option is Wellness Smooth Chicken Loaf. Thankfully, this product holds up in nutritional quality compared to Wellness Core.

As far as nutrition goes, everything is solid. Low in carbs. High in protein from animal foods.

Main downside is it’s only suited for adult cats (sorry senior cats). Some customers report taste and product changes as well, so your mileage may vary.

Key Features:

  • Suitable for all life stages
  • Made in the USA
  • Wet canned cat food

>> Check price of Wellness Smooth Chicken Loaf (Amazon) <<

>> Check price of Wellness Smooth Chicken Loaf (Chewy) <<

4. Ziwi Peak Air-Dried Lamb

Best Dry Cat Food Without Fish

Pros and Cons

  • No fish!
  • No added grains, soy or peas
  • Novel protein lamb to help with allergies
  • Pricey
  • Inconsistent taste reviews

Ziwi Peak Air-Dried lamb is the best dry cat food without fish I found. It does contain added mussels, which might not be what you want…but no other fish ingredients.

As for quality, this cat food is superb. It’s the best dry cat food in the world. Grass-fed quality produce. No added fillers.

The exorbitant price is a big drawback. That again, this food could save you in the long run with vet bills…

Key Features:

  • Suitable for all life stages
  • Made in New Zealand
  • Air-dried cat food

Read More: Ziwi Peak Cat Food Review

>> Check price of Ziwi Peak Air-Dried (Chewy) <<

>> Check price of Ziwi Peak Air-Dried Lamb (Amazon) <<

Ziwi Peak Air-Dried Lamb nutrition information (dry matter analysis)
Ziwi Peak Air-Dried Lamb nutrition information (dry matter analysis)
Ziwi Peak Air-Dried Lamb close up.
A close up look at Ziwi Peak Air-Dried Lamb (has a meaty chunk appearance)

5. Tiki Cat Born Carnivore Deboned Chicken & Egg

Best Affordable Dry Cat Food Without Fish

Pros and Cons

  • No fish!
  • No added soy
  • Chicken as a first ingredient
  • Does contain peas
  • Inconsistent taste reviews

Most dry cat food sucks. Foods are usually loaded with carbs and grains as first ingredients. Fortunately, Tiki Cat Born Carnivore bucks that trend and offers quality without fish.

The first four ingredients are all animal food based which is awesome. Also, the carbs come in at only 13.6% on a dry matter basis – which is startlingly low compared every other dry cat food.

Whilst there’s a few gripes here and there over taste, they’re few and far between. This product does contain peas though, so it might test a sensitive stomach.

Key Features:

  • Suitable for all life stages
  • Made in New Zealand
  • Air-dried cat food

>> Check price on Tiki Cat Born Carnivore Deboned Chicken & Egg (Chewy) <<

>> Check price of Tiki Cat Born Carnivore Deboned Chicken & Egg (Amazon) <<

How Did I Choose These Cat Foods Without Fish?

I have a database of cat foods that I filtered for the following:

  • Fish
  • Salmon
  • Tuna
  • Fish oils (any type)
  • Other fish (e.g. Hoki, Mackerel)
  • Meat by-products

That left me with….not that much! Whilst I’m sure there’s other cat foods out there, my experience is fish-free is the exception, not the norm.

Wellness is the best fish-free popular cat food brand to take a look at (which is why I’ve put down two picks in the review). The picks I’ve chosen reflect better nutrition quality.

Here’s a comparison table of the best wet commercial cat foods without fish:

Best wet cat foods without fishPricePateLifestageProtein*CarbsKcal/kg
Wellness Core Tiny Tasters Duck$$$PateAdult46.7%3.7%1,291
Ziwi Peak Venison Recipe$$$PateAll54.2%10.4%1,200
Feline Natural Chicken & Lamb Feast$$$PateAll51.5%2.1%895
Wellness Smooth Loaf Chicken$$PateAdult47.7%2.6%1,116
Dave’s Naturally Healthy Turkey & Giblets$$PateAdult48.4%3.7%1245
Wellness Morsels With Chicken & Turkey$$ChunksAdult37.1%18.2%725
A comparison of the best wet cat foods without fish *dry matter basis=

Frequently Asked Questions

Can Cats Live Without Fish?

Yes.

Fish is high in essential amino acids and fats, but there’s plenty of other foods with these nutrients.

This includes chicken, beef, turkey and lamb. Any animal-based food will contain similar nutrients that fish provides.

What Do Cats Eat Instead of Fish?

In the wild, cats are carnivores that hunt small prey.

This includes birds, rodents, and insects.

Why Can’t Cats Eat Fish?

Some cats might need to avoid fish due to allergies.

Is It Ok for Cats to Eat Canned Tuna?

Tuna is high in mercury, which is a problem for cats as well.

It’s better for your cats health to avoid or reduce tuna in their diet, using it as an occasional food only.

Learn More:

Canned tuna
Canned tuna is high in mercury. I recommend limiting your cats intake of tuna in the diet.

Should Cats Eat Fish or Chicken?

Cats can eat either in their diet.

Both foods are high in protein, including the essential amino acid taurine, which is beneficial for cats.

If your cat can’t eat fish, there’s no problem with giving them chicken based cat food instead.

Avoid a ‘fish only’ diet. This can cause pansteatitis from vitamin E deficiency or excess unsaturated fats (which increase Vitamin E requirement).

Why Do Cats Like Fish So Much?

Fish is a high quality protein source, which cats prefer. Cats have a strong sense of smell (14x stronger than humans).

No doubt anyone brought in fish into the house will know about it (including your cat).

A cat smelling fish.
Cats have a strong sense of smell (14x stronger than humans) that picks up the smell of fish.

Can a Cat Be Allergic to Fish?

Yes. Fish is a common protein, that cats tend to have a higher risk of being allergic to.

Other common protein sources include beef and chicken.

Signs of fish allergy include:

  • Weight loss
  • Loss of appetite
  • Diarrhea
  • Vomiting
  • Scabs
  • Rubbing face constantly

Does Fish Cause Urinary Problems in Cats?

Not directly, no. Urinary problems are caused by a variety of imbalances in the diet that include:

  • High oxalate food intake
  • Low moisture intake (e.g. dry food only diet)
  • Low phosphorus diets
  • Supplementation with vitamin C

Always consider the total diet. Feeding only fish without other animal foods (including bones and organs) will result in deficiencies.

Do Cats Prefer Fish or Meat?

In experimental settings, cats seem to prefer fish over rodents. Cats have a general preference for high protein foods.

Cat’s have little to no choice in how they are fed. So whilst your cat might love fish, it could just be that they haven’t tried a lot of other foods.

Can Cats Eat Shrimp?

Yes. Shrimp is an excellent high protein food that will help your cat meet their nutrition needs.

Do Cats Eat Fish in Nature?

Cats typically never ate fish in their natural diet. However, they may have been used to hunt fish by Ancient Egyptians.

Cat relaxing.
Cats may have been used to fish by Ancient Egyptians, exposing them to this food.

Conclusion

Some cats are allergic to fish. Other cat owners might want to cut out tuna due to mercury.

Finding cat food without fish is challenging as it’s used a lot in the industry. Fish oil is usually added to boost omega 3 content.

In this article I’ve gone through a few fish-free wet cat foods to look at. Wellness are one pet food brand that makes a lot of a fish-free cat food products.

Our best cat food pick without fish: Feline Natural Chicken & Lamb

Similar Posts